Unsung Founding Fathers

1. Roger Sherman: The Master of Compromise

Roger Sherman distinguished himself as a critical figure at the Constitutional Convention. Known for his ability to forge unanimity among diverse opinions, Sherman devised the Connecticut Compromise, which resolved an impasse between small and large states. This compromise shaped the structure of the U.S. Congress, balancing representation by allotting equal seats in the Senate and proportional representation in the House of Representatives.

Sherman, a self-made man, contributed his expertise at the Constitutional Convention and throughout his career in various public offices. He signed all four great state papers:

  • The Continental Association
  • The Declaration of Independence
  • The Articles of Confederation
  • The Constitution

Despite his substantial contributions, Sherman's role is less celebrated compared to his contemporaries. His impact, however, endures, particularly through his advocacy of a bicameral legislature, which continues to affect legislative processes in the United States today. His work during the convention exemplifies the essential work of building consensus and compromising for the greater good.

Roger Sherman, a pivotal figure at the Constitutional Convention, devised the Connecticut Compromise which balanced representation in the U.S. Congress.

2. Oliver Ellsworth: The Silent Influencer

Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut wielded significant influence during the Constitutional Convention, yet his contributions often go unnoticed. A consummate advocate for a strong federal government, Ellsworth's fingerprint on the Constitution can be seen in the creation of the federal judiciary.

As an experienced jurist, Ellsworth understood the necessity of a balanced judiciary. He proposed the establishment of a federal court system independent of state influence, which laid the foundation for the U.S. Supreme Court. His ideas weathered numerous debates over the judiciary's scope and powers, playing an instrumental role in forming the third branch of government.

Ellsworth stood as a driving force behind the 'Great Compromise' alongside Roger Sherman and contributed to the framing of the 'Lesser Compromise' concerning the determination of the population for purposes of taxation and representation. This involved counting enslaved individuals as three-fifths of a person, a pivotal point in the drafting process.1

Despite resigning as a delegate before the signing of the Constitution due to illness, the measures and frameworks Ellsworth helped establish were critical in shaping its final structure. His expertise in law helped ensure that the newly crafted judiciary became a beacon of balance and justice, aimed at serving the nation impartially. Ellsworth remains a quintessential figure whose silent influence echoes through American legal and governmental institutions.

Oliver Ellsworth, an experienced jurist, played a key role in establishing the federal judiciary as an independent branch of government.

3. William Paterson: Advocate of Small States

Amidst the deliberations of the Constitutional Convention, William Paterson emerged as a staunch advocate for the interests of smaller states, presenting the New Jersey Plan. This plan championed a unicameral legislature, pushing for equal representation regardless of a state's population. This pivotal move came at a crucial time when the debate over representation threatened to fracture the emerging consensus on the new national framework.

Paterson, a former attorney-general of New Jersey and later its governor, brought to Philadelphia a clear vision rooted in protecting the sovereignty and interests of smaller states. While the final Constitution opted for a bicameral legislature, Paterson's influence was felt in the structure of the Senate, where every state would have two senators, maintaining a balance of power.

Paterson's imprint extended beyond the legislative structure. He was instrumental in the framing of Article III of the Constitution, which establishes the judiciary. His commitment to a judicial system that would operate independently of both the executive and legislative branches underscored his intent to preserve a balanced government.

Paterson continued to serve his nation with distinction, eventually being appointed as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court. His legal wisdom and advocacy for state rights during the formation of the Constitution underscore his crucial role as a founding father, securing his legacy as a pivotal architect of American governance.

William Paterson, a staunch advocate for the rights of smaller states, presented the New Jersey Plan at the Constitutional Convention.

4. Edmund Randolph: The Voice of Reason

In the constellation of founding figures who crafted the American Constitution, Edmund Randolph shines as an influential participant. As the Governor of Virginia, he brought to the Constitutional Convention a wealth of political acumen and a belief in strong federal governance.

Randolph introduced the Virginia Plan, an outline that shaped the entire constitution. Drafted by James Madison but presented by Randolph, the plan proposed:

  • A powerful bicameral legislature
  • A robust national government that could assert primacy over state laws, ensuring a uniform policy environment

As debates progressed and drafts altered, Randolph grew increasingly disillusioned with the compromises being made. His legal and philosophical scrutiny could not countenance him fully endorsing all the measures included in the Constitution, such as the Three-Fifths Compromise.

Randolph's commitment to reasoned debate was evidenced by his refusal to sign the Constitution as it stood by the close of the convention. He feared that the Constitution, without a Bill of Rights, accorded too much power to the central government, potentially at the expense of individual liberties.

Upon returning to Virginia, Randolph advocated for the Constitution's ratification, with the provision that it would soon include a Bill of Rights, illustrating his nuanced position of support. He aimed to enhance it through amendments that would secure protections for personal liberties.

Later, as the first U.S. Attorney General and subsequently the Secretary of State, Randolph continued to influence national policy and jurisprudence. His legacy, formed on the pillars of innovation and caution, marked him as a thoughtful statesman whose foresight helped guide the United States during its formative steps.

Edmund Randolph, Governor of Virginia, introduced the influential Virginia Plan at the Constitutional Convention, shaping the structure of the U.S. government.

5. Elbridge Gerry: The Skeptical Signatory

Massachusetts delegate Elbridge Gerry remains a foundational member of the Constitutional Convention circle, encapsulating a crucial aspect of the nation-building dialogue—profound skepticism leading to transformative discourse. Known for his dedication to civil liberties and push for a Bill of Rights, Gerry's refusal to sign the Constitution marked a significant cornerstone in American legal thought, ultimately aiding in the inclusion of the protections that he felt were necessary for safeguarding individual freedoms.

Gerry voiced a critical unease about the potential for governmental overreach and the absence of explicit constraints on federal power throughout the Convention's proceedings. His insights underscore both a passion for democratic ideals and a circumspection about potential governmental absolutism.

During the Convention, Gerry emerged as an advocate for embedding clear delineations of rights into the Constitution, perceiving the absence as a potential for the government to usurp or erode individual freedoms and state sovereignties. His apprehensions were rooted in the belief that a strong central government, unchecked by explicit legal prohibitions, could devolve into tyranny.

Gerry's steadfast position shaped critical discourse at the convention, highlighting the necessity for a balance between federal authority and citizens' protections. He was one of three pivotal figures who openly refused to endorse the document without these assurances.2

In his subsequent political roles, including serving in the U.S. House of Representatives and as the Vice President under James Madison, Gerry's views continued to influence American governance. His commitment to civil discourse and skepticism guided his public service, ensuring that his legacy as a watchdog of democratic values resisted obscurity through the establishment of defenses against governmental overreach.

The imprints left by Elbridge Gerry on United States governance are profound and enduring, instilling a legacy through his direct contributions and via the broader cultural embrace of constitutionally enshrined protection of individual rights. The "skeptical signatory" showcased that dissenting voices could be powerful catalysts for structural improvements, making legislative thoughtfulness and restraint as revolutionary as the ideas that initially sparked the American quest for freedom.

Elbridge Gerry, though refusing to sign the Constitution, played a crucial role in advocating for the inclusion of the Bill of Rights to protect individual liberties.
  1. Beeman R. Plain, Honest Men: The Making of the American Constitution. New York: Random House; 2009.
  2. Collier C, Collier JL. Decision in Philadelphia: The Constitutional Convention of 1787. New York: Ballantine Books; 1986.