Seattle Public Schools Transitions Away from Highly Capable Cohort Model

Seattle Public Schools are transitioning away from the Highly Capable Cohort (HCC) model towards a whole-classroom approach for gifted education. This shift, set to complete by the 2027-28 school year, aims to foster inclusivity and equity.

The new model will integrate students identified as highly capable into neighborhood classrooms, where teachers will differentiate instruction to meet diverse learning needs. This change requires significant adjustments in educational delivery, with teachers designing individual learning plans to support each student's unique talents and learning styles.

The district emphasizes improving access to advanced education services for all students, regardless of background. However, this transition presents challenges for teachers who must now guide a wider range of learning abilities in one classroom. The Universal Design for Learning (UDL) framework will be implemented to promote accessible education customized to individual student needs.

Universal screening processes, mandated by state legislation, will be used to identify students who could benefit from enhanced learning opportunities. This approach aims to eliminate biases in testing procedures and broaden access for students from all walks of life.

While the district is committed to this new model, concerns remain about its practicality and implementation. Parents and teachers question how effectively one teacher can meet the wide range of students' academic requirements without additional resources or support.

Mixed Reactions to the Shift from HCC Model

The shift from the Highly Capable Cohort model has elicited mixed reactions from parents and community members. Many voice concerns about potential pitfalls in this transition.

"It will not help those kids to just cut the program wholesale. We weren't servicing enough of them. You don't help by cutting the program. What we should be doing is identifying more children from underrepresented groups that aren't getting a fair shake in the testing and doing more to fix that and providing these services to more kids across the city," said Simrin Parmar, a parent of a current student in the program.

Key questions arise regarding teacher preparedness and resource allocation. Eric Feeny, another local parent, questioned how one teacher could effectively manage such a diverse range of abilities without experiencing overwhelming stress or compromising educational quality.

Presidents As Kids!

Donald Trump – 45/47th President (2017-2020 / 2025-present)

Joe Biden – 46th President (2021-2024)

George W. Bush – 43rd President (2001–2009)

Jimmy Carter – 39th President (1977–1981)

Bill Clinton – 42nd President (1993–2001)

Gerald Ford – 38th President (1974–1977)

George H. W. Bush – 41st President (1989–1993)

John F. Kennedy – 35th President (1961–1963)

Lyndon B. Johnson – 36th President (1963–1969)

Richard Nixon – 37th President (1969–1974)

Barack Obama – 44th President (2009–2017)

Ronald Reagan – 40th President (1981–1989)

❮ ❯

Concerns and Criticisms:

• Gifted students may not receive the challenges they need to excel
• Potential disengagement or stagnation in academic progression
• Doubts about the district's ability to successfully implement this model given limited resources
• Equitable representation remains central to the debate

While the universal screening process is seen as a progressive step by some, others question its ability to adequately capture the potential of all students, particularly those facing socioeconomic barriers or with less formal test preparation.

As the district moves forward with this educational reform, ongoing engagement and dialogue with the community will be crucial to aligning expectations with the realities of implementing educational equity in Seattle Public Schools.

District's Strategy and Implementation Plan

Superintendent Brent Jones has emphasized the necessity of these changes, stating that the current system does not adequately represent the diversity of the student population. The district's strategy revolves around a multi-tiered support system within the classroom, designed to identify and nurture individual student abilities using diverse data points.

Key Components of the New Model:

1. Universal Screening: Aims to democratize the selection process, eliminating biases that historically favored those with resources for private testing.
2. Whole-Classroom Model: Coupled with Universal Design for Learning (UDL) to adapt teaching styles for diverse learners.
3. Comprehensive Assessment: Tools and criteria developed to ensure a fairer evaluation of students' capabilities and potential.

Recognizing the logistical challenges within existing fiscal constraints, district officials have assured ongoing assessments and modifications based on feedback. They plan to maintain consistent engagement with parents, educators, and stakeholders to manage the conflicting pressures of inclusivity, resource allocation, and educational excellence.

As these initiatives aim to reshape gifted education within Seattle Public Schools, it remains crucial to critically assess whether these reforms adequately support the intended objective of broadening accessibility without sacrificing the nuanced needs of highly capable students.

1. Nester A. Parents Defending Education Investigative Fellow Alex Nester on Seattle Public Schools shutting down gifted and talented program. The National Desk. 2023.
2. Seattle Public Schools. Advanced Learning Services Model. Seattle Public Schools website. 2024.
3. Bazzaz D. Seattle Public Schools is phasing out its highly capable cohort. Will it work? The Seattle Times. 2024.