Constitutional FAQ Answer #11 – The U.S. Constitution Online – USConstitution.net

Constitutional FAQ Answer #11

<<Previous Question |
Question Index |
Subject Index |
Constitutional Index |
Next Question>>

Q11. “Can tabloids be restricted constitutionally?
I don’t mean censor, but can government label tabloids as they label records
with explicit lyrics?”

A. First, it should be clarified that the government does not rate movies,
nor does it rate music, television, or video games. All of these media are
rated by their industries themselves. Movies are rated by the MPAA, and theaters
follow the MPAA rules because it is their industry (in other words, there is no
federal law that defines what an “R” rating is, nor that tells theaters how to
handle R-rated movies). Likewise, the RIAA and record companies rate music. Each
broadcast or cable network rates its own television shows, and the TVPGMB monitors the
ratings. Video games are rated by the ESRB. Though the government has mandated that TV’s
contain V-Chips to allow parents to
control access to rated programming, the rating is still done by a
non-governmental agency.

You can see the MPAA, RIAA, TVPGMB, and ESRB web sites for information on ratings.

With that having been said, it really does not matter if the government
rates movies, music, video games, and TV or not. The press is a special case,
getting specific mention in the Constitution, and its freedom to publish has
long been upheld. A Warning Label? Maybe, but it might have the opposite
desired effect — do you choose R-rated movies, generally, over PG-rated

Last Modified: 16 Aug 2010

Valid HTML 4.0